Publications

27 Results
Skip to search filters

Prescriptive vs. performance based cook-off fire testing

Tieszen, Sheldon R.; Erikson, William W.; Gill, Walt; Blanchat, Tom; Nakos, James T.

In the fire safety community, the trend is toward implementing performance-based standards in place of existing prescriptive ones. Prescriptive standards can be difficult to adapt to changing design methods, materials, and application situations of systems that ultimately must perform well in unwanted fire situations. In general, this trend has produced positive results and is embraced by the fire protection community. The question arises as to whether this approach could be used to advantage in cook-off testing. Prescribed fuel fire cook-off tests have been instigated because of historical incidents that led to extensive damage to structures and loss of life. They are designed to evaluate the propensity for a violent response. The prescribed protocol has several advantages: it can be defined in terms of controllable parameters (wind speed, fuel type, pool size, etc.); and it may be conservative for a particular scenario. However, fires are inherently variable and prescribed tests are not necessarily representative of a particular accident scenario. Moreover, prescribed protocols are not necessarily adaptable and may not be conservative. We also consider performance-based testing. This requires more knowledge and thought regarding not only the fire environment, but the behavior of the munitions themselves. Sandia uses a performance based approach in assuring the safe behavior of systems of interest that contain energetic materials. Sandia also conducts prescriptive fire testing for the IAEA, NRC and the DOT. Here we comment on the strengths and weakness of both approaches and suggest a path forward should it be desirable to pursue a performance based cook-off standard.

More Details

Observations of the cellular structure of fuel-air detonations

Combustion and Flame

Stamps, Douglas W.; Slezak, Scott E.; Tieszen, Sheldon R.

Detonation cell widths, which provide a measure of detonability of a mixture, were measured for hydrocarbon-air and hydrogen-air-diluent mixtures. Results were obtained from a 0.43-m-diameter, 13.1-m-long heated detonation tube with an initial pressure of 101 kPa and an initial temperature between 25 and 100°C. The cell widths of simple cyclic hydrocarbons are somewhat smaller than those of comparable straight-chain alkanes. Cyclic hydrocarbons tested generally had similar cell sizes despite differences in degree of bond saturation, bond strain energy, oxygen substitution, and chemical structure. There was a significant reduction in the cell width of octane, a straight-chain alkane, when it was mixed with small quantities of hexyl nitrate. The effect of a diluent, such as steam and carbon dioxide, on the cell width of a hydrogen-air mixture is shown over a wide range of mixture stoichiometries. The data illustrate the effects of initial temperature and pressure on the cell width when compared to previous studies. Not only is carbon dioxide more effective than steam at increasing the mixture cell width, but also its effectiveness increases relative to that of steam with increasing concentrations. The detonability limits, which are dependent on the facility geometry and type of initiator used in this study, were measured for fuel-lean and fuel-rich hydrogen-air mixtures and stoichiometric hydrogen-air mixtures diluted with steam. The detonability limits are nominally at the flammability limits for hydrogen-air mixtures. The subcellular structure within a fuel-lean hydrogen-air detonation cell was recorded using a sooted foil. The uniform fine structure of the self-sustained transverse wave and the irregular structure of the overdriven lead shock wave are shown at the triple point path that marks the boundary between detonation cells.

More Details

A turbulence model for buoyant flows based on vorticity generation

Nicolette, Vernon F.; Tieszen, Sheldon R.; Black, Amalia R.; Domino, Stefan P.; O'Hern, Timothy J.

A turbulence model for buoyant flows has been developed in the context of a k-{var_epsilon} turbulence modeling approach. A production term is added to the turbulent kinetic energy equation based on dimensional reasoning using an appropriate time scale for buoyancy-induced turbulence taken from the vorticity conservation equation. The resulting turbulence model is calibrated against far field helium-air spread rate data, and validated with near source, strongly buoyant helium plume data sets. This model is more numerically stable and gives better predictions over a much broader range of mesh densities than the standard k-{var_epsilon} model for these strongly buoyant flows.

More Details

Guidance on risk analysis and safety implications of a large liquefied natural gas (LNG) spill over water

Hightower, Marion M.; Morrow, Charles W.; Covan, John M.; Gritzo, Louis A.; Luketa, Anay L.; Tieszen, Sheldon R.; Wellman, Gerald W.; Kaneshige, Michael J.; Melof, Brian M.

While recognized standards exist for the systematic safety analysis of potential spills or releases from LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas) storage terminals and facilities on land, no equivalent set of standards or guidance exists for the evaluation of the safety or consequences from LNG spills over water. Heightened security awareness and energy surety issues have increased industry's and the public's attention to these activities. The report reviews several existing studies of LNG spills with respect to their assumptions, inputs, models, and experimental data. Based on this review and further analysis, the report provides guidance on the appropriateness of models, assumptions, and risk management to address public safety and property relative to a potential LNG spill over water.

More Details

On the fluid mechanics of fires

Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics

Tieszen, Sheldon R.

Fluid mechanics research related to fire is reviewed with focus on canonical flows, multiphysics coupling aspects, experimental and numerical techniques. Fire is a low-speed, chemically-reacting, flow in which buoyancy plans an important role. Fire research has focused on two canonical flows, the reacting boundary-layer and the reacting free plume. There is rich, multi-lateral, bi-directional, coupling among fluid mechanics and scalar transport, combustion, and radiation. There is only a limited experimental fluid-mechanics database for fire due to measurement difficulties in the harsh environment, and the focus within the fire community on thermal/chemical consequences. Increasingly, computational fluid dynamics techniques are being used to provide engineering guidance on thermal/chemical consequences and to study fire phenomenology.

More Details

A spray-suppression model for turbulent combustion

DesJardin, Paul E.; Tieszen, Sheldon R.; Gritzo, Louis A.

A spray-suppression model that captures the effects of liquid suppressant on a turbulent combusting flow is developed and applied to a turbulent diffusion flame with water spray suppression. The spray submodel is based on a stochastic separated flow approach that accounts for the transport and evaporation of liquid droplets. Flame extinguishment is accounted for by using a perfectly stirred reactor (PSR) submodel of turbulent combustion. PSR pre-calculations of flame extinction times are determined using CHEMKIN and are compared to local turbulent time scales of the flow to determine if local flame extinguishment has occurred. The PSR flame extinguishment and spray submodels are incorporated into Sandia's flow fire simulation code, VULCAN, and cases are run for the water spray suppression studies of McCaffrey for turbulent hydrogen-air jet diffusion flames. Predictions of flame temperature decrease and suppression efficiency are compared to experimental data as a function of water mass loading using three assumed values of drop sizes. The results show that the suppression efficiency is highly dependent on the initial droplet size for a given mass loading. A predicted optimal suppression efficiency was observed for the smallest class of droplets while the larger drops show increasing suppression efficiency with increasing mass loading for the range of mass loadings considered. Qualitative agreement to the experiment of suppression efficiency is encouraging, however quantitative agreement is limited due to the uncertainties in the boundary conditions of the experimental data for the water spray.

More Details

Time and length scales within a fire and implications for numerical simulation

Tieszen, Sheldon R.

A partial non-dimensionalization of the Navier-Stokes equations is used to obtain order of magnitude estimates of the rate-controlling transport processes in the reacting portion of a fire plume as a function of length scale. Over continuum length scales, buoyant times scales vary as the square root of the length scale; advection time scales vary as the length scale, and diffusion time scales vary as the square of the length scale. Due to the variation with length scale, each process is dominant over a given range. The relationship of buoyancy and baroclinc vorticity generation is highlighted. For numerical simulation, first principles solution for fire problems is not possible with foreseeable computational hardware in the near future. Filtered transport equations with subgrid modeling will be required as two to three decades of length scale are captured by solution of discretized conservation equations. By whatever filtering process one employs, one must have humble expectations for the accuracy obtainable by numerical simulation for practical fire problems that contain important multi-physics/multi-length-scale coupling with up to 10 orders of magnitude in length scale.

More Details

On the development of a subgrid CFD model for fire extinguishment

Tieszen, Sheldon R.; Black, Amalia R.

A subgrid model is presented for use in CFD fire simulations to account for thermal suppressants and strain. The extinguishment criteria is based on the ratio of a local fluid-mechanics time-scale to a local chemical time-scale compared to an empirically-determined critical Damkohler number. Local extinction occurs if this time scale is exceeded, global fire extinguishment occurs when local extinction has occurred for all combusting cells. The fluid mechanics time scale is based on the Kolmogorov time scale and the chemical time scale is based on blowout of a perfectly stirred reactor. The input to the reactor is based on cell averaged temperatures, assumed stoichiometric fuel/air composition, and cell averaged suppressant concentrations including combustion products. A detailed chemical mechanism is employed. The chemical time-scale is precalculated and mixing rules are used to reduce the composition space that must be parameterized. Comparisons with experimental data for fire extinguishment in a flame-stabilizing, backward-facing step geometry indicates that the model is conservative for this condition.

More Details
27 Results
27 Results