The effect of crystallography on transgranular chloride-induced stress corrosion cracking (TGCISCC) of arc welded 304L austenitic stainless steel is studied on >300 grains along crack paths. Schmid and Taylor factor mismatches across grain boundaries (GBs) reveal that cracks propagate either from a hard to soft grain, which can be explained merely by mechanical arguments, or soft to hard grain. In the latter case, finite element analysis reveals that TGCISCC will arrest at GBs without sufficient mechanical stress, favorable crystallographic orientations, or crack tip corrosion. GB type does not play a significant role in determining TGCISCC cracking behavior nor susceptibility. TGCISCC crack behaviors at GBs are discussed in the context of the competition between mechanical, crystallographic, and corrosion factors.
This progress report describes work performed during FY22 at Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) to assess the corrosion performance of cold spray coatings to enable optimization of cold spray for the purposes of mitigation and/or repair of potentially susceptible regions, corrosion, or stress corrosion cracking (SCC) in austenitic stainless steel for spent nuclear fuel (SNF) storage. Of particular concern is SCC, by which a through-wall crack could potentially form in a canister outer wall over time intervals that may be shorter than possible dry storage times. In FY21, initial corrosion explorations of cold spray coating were evaluated and in FY22, an expanded set of cold spray coatings with in-depth analysis of post-exposure accelerated testing was explored. Additionally, relevant atmospheric exposure testing was carried out and initial results are presented herein. The corrosion attack from the accelerated testing and more realistic atmospheric exposures environments were compared to identify potentially deleterious factors for corrosion as well as help to understand the applicability of accelerated testing for cold spray optimization. This initial analysis will help to enable optimization of the corrosion resistance cold spray, one of the more promising coating and repair techniques, for potential application in an SNF environment. Learnings from both are summarized, and implications and future work are presented in this report.
Qu, Haozheng J.; Srinivasan, Jayendran; Zhao, Yangyang; Mao, Keyou S.; Taylor, Jason M.; Marino, Gabriella; Montoya, Timothy M.; Johnson, Kyle; Locke, Jenifer S.; Schaller, Rebecca S.; Schindelholz, Eric; Wharry, Janelle P.
The chloride-induced stress corrosion cracking (CISCC) mechanism of cold spray (CS) coating on a galvanically similar substrate is investigated. Arc welded 304L stainless steel (SS) specimens are loaded into four-point bend fixtures, cold sprayed with 304L SS, then immersed in boiling MgCl2. Interconnected porosity forms through crevice corrosion along CS splat boundaries, allowing corrosive species to penetrate through the CS layer. Nevertheless, the substrate is resistant to CISCC likely because of compressive stress introduced by peening during CS particle impacts. These findings underscore the importance of residual stress in the environmental degradation of CS coatings or repairs of engineering structures.
Residual stress is a contributor to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) and a common byproduct of additive manufacturing (AM). Here the relationship between residual stress and SCC susceptibility in laser powder bed fusion AM 316L stainless steel was studied through immersion in saturated boiling magnesium chloride per ASTM G36-94. The residual stress was varied by changing the sample height for the as-built condition and additionally by heat treatments at 600°C, 800°C, and 1,200°C to control, and in some cases reduce, residual stress. In general, all samples in the as-built condition showed susceptibility to SCC with the thinner, lower residual stress samples showing shallower cracks and crack propagation occurring perpendicular to melt tracks due to local residual stress fields. The heat-treated samples showed a reduction in residual stress for the 800°C and 1,200°C samples. Both were free of cracks after >300 h of immersion in MgCl2, while the 600°C sample showed similar cracking to their as-built counterpart. Geometrically necessary dislocation (GND) density analysis indicates that the dislocation density may play a major role in the SCC susceptibility.
Additively manufactured (AM) stainless steels (SSs) exhibit numerous microstructural differences compared to their wrought counterparts, such as Cr-enriched dislocation cell structures. The influence these unique features have on a SSs corrosion resistance are still under investigation with most current works limited to laboratory experiments. The work herein shows the first documented study of AM 304L and 316L exposed to a severe marine environment on the eastern coast of Florida with comparisons made to wrought counterparts. Coupons were exposed for 21 months and resulted in significant pitting corrosion to initiate after 1 month of exposure for all conditions. At all times, the AM coupons exhibited lower average and maximum pit depths than their wrought counterparts. After 21 months, pits on average were 4 μm deep for AM 316L specimen and 8 μm deep for wrought specimen. Pits on the wrought samples tended to be nearly hemispherical and polished with some pits showing crystallographic attack while pits on AM coupons exhibited preferential attack at melt pool boundaries and the cellular microstructure.
Ground 304 stainless steel (SS) samples were exposed to sea salt particles at 35 °C and two relative humidity (RH) levels for durations ranging from 1 week to 2 years. For all exposure times, pit number density and total pit volume at 40% RH were observed to be considerably greater than those at 76% RH. Statistical analysis of distributions of pit populations for both RH conditions showed that pit number density and total pit volume increased rapidly at first but slowed as exposure time increased. Cross-hatched features were observed in the 40% RH pits while ellipsoidal, faceted pits were observed at 76% RH. Optical profilometry indicated that most pits were not hemispherical. X-ray tomography provided evidence of undercutting and fissures. Piecewise curve fitting modeled the 40% RH data closely, predicting that corrosion damage would eventually plateau. However, a similar treatment of the 76% RH data suggested that corrosion damage would continuously increase, which implied that the piecewise power-law fit was limited in its ability to model atmospheric corrosion generally. Based on these observations, the operative mechanisms determining long-term corrosion behavior were hypothesized to be different depending on the RH of exposure.
For long-term storage, spent nuclear fuel (SNF) is placed in dry storage systems, commonly consisting of welded stainless steel canisters enclosed in ventilated overpacks. Choride-induced stress corrosion cracking (CISCC) of these canisters may occur due to the deliquescence of sea-salt aerosols as the canisters cool. Current experimental and modeling efforts to evaluate canister CISCC assume that the deliquescent brines, once formed, persist on the metal surface, without changing chemical or physical properties. Here we present data that show that magnesium chloride rich-brines, which form first as the canisters cool and sea-salts deliquesce, are not stable at elevated temperatures, degassing HCl and converting to solid carbonates and hydroxychloride phases, thus limiting conditions for corrosion. Moreover, once pitting corrosion begins on the metal surface, oxygen reduction in the cathode region surrounding the pits produces hydroxide ions, increasing the pH under some experimental conditions, leads to precipitation of magnesium hydroxychloride hydrates. Because magnesium carbonates and hydroxychloride hydrates are less deliquescent than magnesium chloride, precipitation of these compounds causes a reduction in the brine volume on the metal surface, potentially limiting the extent of corrosion. If taken to completion, such reactions may lead to brine dry-out, and cessation of corrosion.
The corrosion behavior of selective laser melted (SLM) 304L was investigated and compared to conventional wrought 304L in aqueous chloride and acidic solutions. Through immersed electrochemical testing and exposure in acidic solutions, the SLM 304L exhibited superior pitting resistance in the polished state compared to wrought 304L. However, the surface condition of the SLM material had a great impact on its corrosion resistance, with the grit-blasted condition exhibiting severely diminished pitting resistance. Local scale, capillary micro-electrochemical and scanning electrochemical microscopy investigations, identified porosity as a contributing factor to decreased corrosion resistance. Preferential corrosion attack was not observed to be related to the characteristic underlying cellular microstructure produced through SLM processing. This study highlights the effects of SLM microstructural features on corrosion resistance, specifically the substantial influence of surface finish on SLM corrosion behavior and the need for development and optimization of processing techniques to improve surface finish.
The corrosion susceptibility of a laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) additively manufactured alloy, UNS S17400 (17-4 PH), was explored compared to conventional wrought material. Microstructural characteristics were characterized and related to corrosion behavior in quiescent, aqueous 0.6 M NaCl solutions. Electrochemical measurements demonstrated that the LPBF 17-4 PH alloy exhibited a reduced passivity range and active corrosion compared to its conventional wrought counterpart. A microelectrochemical cell was used to further understand the effects of the local scale and attributed the reduced corrosion resistance of the LPBF material to pores with diameters ≥50 μm.
Metal additive manufacturing (AM) has recently become a desirable process for complex parts across a broad range of applications. However, AM materials often have a varied microstructure due to non-equilibrium solidification conditions. While some adjustments have been made in manufacturing to enhance mechanical traits, very little attention has been directed at understanding the corrosion properties of these materials. The microstructural characteristics of the AM materials may lead to reduction in the corrosion resistance of the AM alloys compared to their conventional counterparts. This presentation explores the corrosion susceptibility of AM stainless steels in aqueous sodium chloride environments as well as industry relevant solutions. Further detailed corrosion studies combined with microstructural characterization provide insight into the microstructural influences on corrosion.
Corrosion of aluminum and aluminum alloys under atmospheric exposure has been well documented for outdoor conditions. While these studies expose the effects of environmental severity they do not explicitly establish the dependence of corrosion rate on salt loading. Accelerated laboratory studies have shown that initial corrosion rates are generally higher with higher salt loadings, but, over time corrosion appears to effectively stifle for low loadings of NaCl (<100 μg/cm2) under fixed humidity conditions. This has previously been attributed to the stability or passivation of the surface that is pH and, in turn, CO2 dependent. Another possible explanation could be the gettering of NaCl by corrosion product leading to surface drying and depletion of the corrosion aggressor. This paper explores the effects of selected NaCl loading densities vs. exposure time of UNS A91100 at both the macro and micro scale to illuminate the possible mechanisms leading to corrosion stifling. Through this work, an understanding of the relationship between corrosion in atmospheric systems versus the variation of a specific environmental severity factor, NaCl loading density, will be further developed.
Three balance of systems (BOS) connector designs common to industry were investigated as a means of assessing reliability from the perspective of arc fault risk. These connectors were aged in field and laboratory environments and performance data captured for future development of a reliability model. Comparison of connector resistance measured during damp heat, mixed flowing gas and field exposure in a light industrial environment indicated disparities in performance across the three designs. Performance was, in part, linked to materials of construction. A procedure was developed to evaluate new and aged connectors for arc fault risk and tested for one of the designs. Those connectors exposed to mixed flowing gas corrosion exhibited considerable Joule heating that may enhance arcing behavior, suggesting temperature monitoring as a potential method for arc fault prognostics. These findings, together with further characterization of connector aging, can provide operators of photovoltaic installations the information necessary to develop a data-driven approach to BOS connector maintenance as well as opportunities for arc fault prognostics.
This work investigates balance of systems (BOS) connector reliability from the perspective of arc fault risk. Accelerated tests were performed on connectors for future development of a reliability model. Thousands of hours of damp heat and atmospheric corrosion tests found BOS connectors to be resilient to corrosion-related degradation. A procedure was also developed to evaluate new and aged connectors for arc fault risk. The measurements show that arc fault risk is dependent on a combination of materials composition as well as design geometry. Thermal measurements as well as optical emission spectroscopy were also performed to further characterize the arc plasma. Together, the degradation model, arc fault risk assessment technique, and characterization methods can provide operators of photovoltaic installations information necessary to develop a data-driven plan for BOS connector maintenance as well as identify opportunities for arc fault prognostics.