Publications

Experimental credibility and its role in model validation and decision making

Kieweg, Sarah K.; Witkowski, Walter R.

Experiments are a critical part of the model validation process, and the credibility of the resulting simulations are themselves dependent on the credibility of the experiments. The impact of experimental credibility on model validation occurs at several points through the model validation and uncertainty quantification (MVUQ) process. Many aspects of experiments involved in the development and verification and validation (V&V) of computational simulations will impact the overall simulation credibility. In this document, we define experimental credibility in the context of model validation and decision making. We summarize possible elements for evaluating experimental credibility, sometimes drawing from existing and preliminary frameworks developed for evaluation of computational simulation credibility. The proposed framework is an expert elicitation tool for planning, assessing, and communicating the completeness and correctness of an experiment (“test”) in the context of its intended use—validation. The goals of the assessment are (1) to encourage early communication and planning between the experimentalist, computational analyst, and customer, and (2) the communication of experimental credibility. This assessment tool could also be used to decide between potential existing data sets to be used for validation. The evidence and story of experimental credibility will support the communication of overall simulation credibility.