Sandia LabNews

Electrical circuits encased in fluid may reshape data-center design


Water and power increases for cooling no longer inevitable

COOLING OFF — David Smith, front, and Dave Martinez, behind, work on a computer server submerged in liquid as part of testing at the High Performance Computing center at Sandia. The immersion system uses a nonconductive liquid coolant that enables 100% of the heat generated to be captured. The reflection of the computer demonstrates the high liquid level. (Photo by Craig Fritz)
COOLING OFF — David Smith, front, and Dave Martinez, behind, work on a computer server submerged in liquid as part of testing at the High Performance Computing center at Sandia. The immersion system uses a nonconductive liquid coolant that enables 100% of the heat generated to be captured. The reflection of the computer demonstrates the high liquid level. (Photo by Craig Fritz)
Image of innovation-logo

Keeping electrical circuits dry is generally considered a vital safety measure, but at Sandia’s High Performance Computing center, technicians adjust live circuits submerged in liquid.

“It’s pretty cool — and a little unusual — to walk into a computing lab and see electrical hardware submerged in fluid,” Sandia engineer David Damm said.

Complete immersion of computer components appears to be the most effective way to cool them, said Dave Martinez, engineering program project lead for Sandia’s Infrastructure Computing Services. “We place whole computers — their power cables, everything — in a liquefied solution. We take an entire rack and drop it into fluid contained in big immersion tanks.”

He believes that this direct contact between a liquid coolant and electrified equipment “could reshape the future designs of data centers.”

Reshaping data-center architectures

COLD PLUNGE — David Smith makes network connections to a computer server submerged in liquid as part of testing at the high performance computing center at Sandia. (Video by Craig Fritz)
COLD PLUNGE — David Smith makes network connections to a computer server submerged in liquid as part of testing at the high performance computing center at Sandia. (Video by Craig Fritz)

By submerging all parts of the computing servers in a liquid coolant that doesn’t conduct electricity, 100% of the generated heat can be captured, almost entirely eliminating the need for the power-hungry fans and chillers used in conventional cooling systems.

Dave estimates that this type of cooling system, using liquid approximately the viscosity of cooking oil, would cut energy consumption by 70%. Unlike water-chill systems that require evaporation to lower operating temperatures, no water is lost; the coolant gives up its heat to the open air, given the right temperature differential.

Sandia’s forward-thinking approach arises from projections that the increasing water and electrical power demands for cooling in high-performance computing eventually will exceed the resources of small towns and become an unsupportable burden.

To address this, Sandia is formally testing a commercial nonconductive liquid system from Barcelona-based company Submer Technologies throughout the summer. Early positive results led Dave to envision a reduction in the two big problem areas of power and water use that are expected to hinder the development of faster, more powerful machines.

Promising innovations and partnerships

According to the Submer website, their single-phase immersion cooling system uses a biodegradable, nontoxic, nonflammable and noncorrosive liquid. It boasts being 95% more efficient than traditional cooling technologies, while 1,400 times a better thermal conductor than air and eight times less electrically conductive.

TEMPERATURE DROP — Hoan Luu, left, and David Damm work on a computer server submerged in liquid. Save for the silver handles at the top, the entire computer server is submerged. (Photo by Craig Fritz)
TEMPERATURE DROP — Hoan Luu, left, and David Damm work on a computer server submerged in liquid. Save for the silver handles at the top, the entire computer server is submerged. (Photo by Craig Fritz)

Negotiating through Adacen Inc., a local Albuquerque data company, Dave convinced Submer to partner with Sandia. Submer would provide fluid and equipment and Sandia would provide its expertise in system cooling and testing to perform a thorough technical evaluation of the system. Meanwhile, Dave, who for 25 years has worked diligently to bring about the next stages of computer cooling, is happy to reduce Sandia’s costs for power and water and provide a stage for a potential revolution for the industry.

In partnership with Adacen, code is being written specifically for the new task by Hoonify Technologies, composed of five former Sandia researchers who have taken entrepreneurial leave from the Labs.

In 2020, Submer, in collaboration with Intel Corp., introduced the idea of a liquid coolant that would bathe all components of a computing system to provide even cooling and allow higher operating temperatures.

As a bonus, the warmer temperature of the returning liquid can offer some heat to adjacent buildings during winter months and can be used to heat labs and showers in the summer through heat-exchange processes.

Sandia will conduct comprehensive tests on this system, evaluating hardware reliability and infrastructure support cost and effort. A case study is expected to be released this fall to assess the pros and cons of the technology.

Meet Dave Martinez: Innovating energy-efficient data center solutions

Dave Martinez, engineering program project lead for Sandia’s Infrastructure Computing Services, envisions building the most energy-efficient data center in the world. This center would aim not only to reduce energy consumption but also to use waste heat for various purposes, including heating buildings and preheating lab water, he said. Dave leads Sandia’s involvement in COOLERCHIPS, a DOE Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy initiative aimed at defining the future of liquid cooling in high-performance computing. Additionally, he plays a significant role in Energy Efficient High Performance Computing, a worldwide organization with 1,000 members, where he serves as the infrastructure lead.

Throughout his career, Dave has witnessed the evolution of computer cooling methods from liquid to air and back to liquid cooling. With a keen interest in the thermodynamics of computing systems, he has been actively involved in power and cooling solutions for nearly four decades. Notable contributions include assisting in the design of energy-efficient data centers, such as the one at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, which currently boasts the world’s most energy-efficient data center with 80% heat recapture.

Dave’s dedication over the past 25 years has been pivotal in shaping the future of power and cooling solutions in computing, reflecting his commitment to advancing sustainable and efficient technologies in the field.

Recent articles by Neal Singer